Well I picked up this new toy today, the M&P 15-22, for $335 + $35 local FFL fee (seem to remember it being $20 last time, but oh well). I haven't shot it yet, but it seems like it will be a blast to play with. My initial impressions are that it is very light, and feels very plasticy - almost like a toy - because, well it's made mostly of plastic/polymer. It feels about half as light as a real AR, and the magazine didn't slide out when I hit the release. The charging handle doesn't come out as far either, but I read about that and the polymer upper/lower thing so none of this was a surprise. The MBUS sights and stock are as expected - real. Also moving the safety felt kind of cheap (again due to the polymer) and you can see the model number is molded into the polymer as opposed to stamped like it would be with metal. But no big deal there either. Seems to break down similar to a regular AR as well.
While at the local gun store, I handled the Shield as well as the Glock 43. I'm tall with XL hands (at least that's what size nitrile gloves and Home Depot work glove size I wear, LOL). The 43 didn't fit in my hand - I thought they sawed off the last inch of the grip. I asked the lady for the pinky extension thing and she said it was already on! The Shield was a very comfortable fit, and my pinky sat nicely on the extension of the +1 magazine that comes with it. From online reading only, i was all but sold on the Glock 43, but now I am totally sold on the M&P shield (maybe next month after the wife finds out about this last buy). There was something about the grip as well that just felt right. I didn't have time to shoot either of them (they have rentals there at the range).
So I wanted the Shield with the thumb safety, but they only had the 9mm without for $430, which I thought was a tad high. She did have a .40 Shield, with safety and with Crimson Trace laser for $430 also. That seemed like a great deal, but I am not sure if I want to go the .40 route, mainly due to the ammo cost and because I think ammo will go up in price in the future as more departments get away from that caliber. Plus I hadn't even considered a laser on a concealed carry until playing with this one. It didn't add hardly any weight or extra length/width to the pistol. Both the .40 and the 9mm shield seemed to weight the exact same and have almost the exact same dimensions. You lose a round with the .40, but according the lady there, the .40 packs much more of a punch (I know, I know, there is a lot of controversy there and it wasn't the time to start a long discussion with her).
The crappy thing is that I will have to pay local sales tax, which would make the above guns more in the $470 range each. I can find these online for like $320 with a $30 FFL fee. Part of me wants to buy local and support the local shop, especially after the help they gave me, but a big part of me feels like I am getting ripped off with the $100+ higher price.