Toro is pretty much spot on with all of his comments. The overall grade for your sortie does not matter......it's the individual grades for the ride that go into your score....albeit a pretty small portion. The biggest chunk of it comes (sts) from your checkrides. And yes, you are right, all of your grades ARE very subjective. While all of us IPs try to grade again the Phase Training Standards (Toro, MIF just lists each item to be accomplished and what grade it needs to be by end of block....PTS actually defines numbers such as airspeed +- 10KIAS, etc), it's the grey areas that are up to our interpretation. And, unfortunately for you, those grey areas usually make up about 90% of the sortie....very rarely is anything black and white. That's why we get paid the big bucks..to make those decisions.
No shlt? EVERY one? Or even almost every one? You all really give marginals out at the beginning of a phase? So basically, you expect them to be proficient in them that early...no learning curve? Hmmmm.......
Either way, unless they really do give all marginals at the beginning of a phase(NOT how we do it at Sheppard), your USEM/SELO should have definately told you if you received a marginal....
[ 05. January 2007, 07:29: Message edited by: ENJJPT IP ]