No argument here.
That may be true, but you're missing one very important fact. The VSP was not targeted at flyers. The VSP was targeted at ALL officers in a specific range of year groups. The bean counters were given a mandate to come up with a simple way to slash the force. They answered with a program that only used two variables: AFSC and year group. First to apply, first accepted. The folks that designed that program probably don't know f*ck all about ops, and therefore didn't even flinch when they started typing in 11x AFSC's into the spreadsheet. My point is, the main body of folks they were targeting probably didn't have the same kind of ops tempo we did (with a few exceptions like Cops, LROs, etc.), and were much more tentative about getting out. They needed a push and VSP served that purpose. The fact that flyers were allowed out the door under the same conditions was a major "oh sh!t" that was probably only realized after it was too late.
As a VSPer turned Guard Bum without a civilian job, I have to disagree. I wouldn't trade my AD service for anything, but I'm happy where I'm at. Even if I have to beg for man-days and live a more frugal lifestyle, I'm not coming back and I know a lot of other VSPers who feel the same way.
I seriously doubt the VSPers are going to be getting all the good deals...Creech and Cannon will be pretty much the only choices with few exceptions. I will say this, if you resent the VSPers because you're jealous of what we got (and may be able to get in the future) you need to take a hard look in the mirror. Don't hate the player, hate the game. I knew exactly what was going to happen the moment the VSP announcement hit my inbox. The writing was already on the wall WRT the non-vol 365s at that point. Without the VSP I would have happily served out my commitment and then faced a tough choice with 12 years already served. When big blue offered the out, we all knew those who didn't take it stood a much greater chance of "winning" the non-vol lottery.
Agreed. If I went back I would expect nothing less.