Very true on your argument. Apparently how the grading system worked was that everybody started off as an Excellent on every single graded item on a checkride, I $hit you not, plus this is the quote from the IP from my debrief. Yes I know it's sick how I remember this, "So we fly out once, strike one, downgraded to good. We fly out twice, strike two, downgraded to Fair. Fly out three times (which I still stand-by it being questionable), strike three, I'm out." Again, this is how I remember it.