I think I've given more Q1s with downgrades than I've given clean Q1s, but I've also never given a Q3, and honestly do not see the point of a Q2. That's an evaluator with no guts. Either put your instructor hat on and fix it in the debrief, or have the guts to Q3 them and defend your decision. Had a couple of cases that could've been argued into a Q3 by strictest interpretation of the Vol 2, but in my perspective the benefit of the doubt goes to the evaluatee. So, noted it, gave a downgrade in the appropriate area, debriefed it, and we moved on with life. At the end of the day, even with a downgrade your 942 is going to say Q1.