Jump to content

Herk hard landing - Afghanistan


Recommended Posts

I will ask this though... Is there any reason that a fresh-out-of-the-schoolhouse -J guy shouldn't be able to stick a landing into any of those three fields without bending metal?

A pilot can prang an airplane in anywhere. A pilot can input the TOLD wrong anywhere. It doesn't have to be in Afghanistan.

A fresh new J guy 'should' be able to.. but Afghanistan is very different than CONUS. High elevations/max gross weights/defensive systems are not taught in unison so task saturation and maturity (especially for GW considerations) are not there yet. A few rides in those conditions and its natural again, but those few rides are still educational over there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Trust me, I've been there. I get it.

I'm not shitting on the crew at all. I understand... "shit happens".

My point is that the conditions in Afghanistan are not so unique that it is impossible for us to establish good habit patterns at home so that we are ready to do the Lord's work when we arrive in theater.

Whenever our next adventure kicks off, we are not going to have the luxury of "over the shoulder" educational rides in a mature, uncontested theater like we enjoy right now.

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

A fresh new J guy 'should' be able to.. but Afghanistan is very different than CONUS. High elevations/max gross weights/defensive systems are not taught in unison so task saturation and maturity (especially for GW considerations) are not there yet. A few rides in those conditions and its natural again, but those few rides are still educational over there.

This. As a brand new AC in the sandbox right now, I can attest to this. My first flight out here was surprising to me-way different than what we train for back home. Airmanship isn't truly tested until you are removed from your safe cookie cutter conus training environment and you are faced with a situation like this:

One controller (atc) wants you to go left for traffic, but you don't wanna go left because there's a thunderstorm there. Another controller (c2) wants you to go right because there is a roz in front of you because some a-10s are blowing shit up, but you don't wanna go right because there's a ######ing mountain there. You can't climb because you don't have the performance yet. Your copilot and nav are telling you different things based on the controller they are talking to. Your eng is worried about the number four tit gauge which decided to stop working, and your load is worried about the bright flashing light off of your left wing which is probably just a pickup truck but could be something more. Obviously several options available, but typically not something you encounter back home and if you don't have your head on a swivel, you could easily decide to do something that could bend metal and kill people.

I'm sure every aircraft has similar stories. I've seen the wreckage, and carried passengers on the plane in question. Ill reserve judgement, because I know everyone has been put in a situation where after they landed, they heaved a sigh of relief because whatever they ######ed up didn't result in the worst case scenario.

Edited by Oo7kerpow
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This. As a brand new AC in the sandbox right now, I can attest to this. My first flight out here was surprising to me-way different than what we train for back home. Airmanship isn't truly tested until you are removed from your safe cookie cutter conus training environment and you are faced with a situation like this:

One controller (atc) wants you to go left for traffic, but you don't wanna go left because there's a thunderstorm there. Another controller (c2) wants you to go right because there is a roz in front of you because some a-10s are blowing shit up, but you don't wanna go right because there's a ######ing mountain there. You can't climb because you don't have the performance yet. Your copilot and nav are telling you different things based on the controller they are talking to. Your eng is worried about the number four tit gauge which decided to stop working, and your load is worried about the bright flashing light off of your left wing which is probably just a pickup truck but could be something more. Obviously several options available, but typically not something you encounter back home and if you don't have your head on a swivel, you could easily decide to do something that could bend metal and kill people.

I'm sure every aircraft has similar stories. I've seen the wreckage, and carried passengers on the plane in question. Ill reserve judgement, because I know everyone has been put in a situation where after they landed, they heaved a sigh of relief because whatever they ######ed up didn't result in the worst case scenario.

C2 doesn't know their ass from a hole in the ground. And ATC out there is convinced the world was built in 7 days to service their every desire, and nothing more. C2 aimed so many UAVs at our plane I was starting to think their was a medal for creating the most HATRs, and ATC told me that even though we were going to run out of gas, we could not land at AIX or AKB because POTUS was parked there. Good luck, it'll be your fault no matter what happens. Therein lies the key to serenity.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Trust me, I've been there. I get it.

I'm not shitting on the crew at all. I understand... "shit happens".

My point is that the conditions in Afghanistan are not so unique that it is impossible for us to establish good habit patterns at home so that we are ready to do the Lord's work when we arrive in theater.

Whenever our next adventure kicks off, we are not going to have the luxury of "over the shoulder" educational rides in a mature, uncontested theater like we enjoy right now.

Yes, we should be able to establish good habit patterns at home, but that would mean we actually focus on flying and there are flying training hours available. Otherwise, we are just stuck doing the minimums to meet RAP or currency so we look good on paper. After all, we have a Christmas party to plan...ain't nobody got time for flying! Edited by BitteEinBit
Link to comment
Share on other sites

LockheedFix, I've never flown the KC-135 but I have many friends that do. I'd imagine it is pretty damn difficult to land an aircraft with only 16" clearance on the inboard engines in crosswinds, something high wing aircraft don't really have to worry about. If I remember right, they only have 4 degrees of bank on landing before scraping an engine. Frankly, I'm surprised it doesn't happen more

After an interesting and less than respectful PM, this asshole has been put in a permanent time out. If anybody happens to run across a douchebag from Maryland with the email address pilotwannabe@outlook.com, kick him in the nuts for me.

  • Upvote 8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Had several good looks at the aircraft since the incident...it's a total write off. Vertical stab was hacked off about a week or two ago as it's right on final for the runway. Looking forward to reading the report. I honestly have no idea how this happened, but I'm sure the crew didn't either. As a Herc guy flying over here as a civilian, I see much boobery by Herc crews, and sometimes it's embarassing, but sometimes, I can't blame them. The crews I see here look very young and I'm sure it's their first time here for some. I don't know if they're just reading too much into it or what, but flying here is not that cosmic if you can filter out all of the extraneous bs. Their Tactics shops should be briefing them to remember one thing: Airmanship. C2 will try and fly you into terrain. ATC will do the same. Use your heads, your training, your TCAS and your crew. Be smart. If ATC tells you to do something stupid, tell them no. But none of that explains that landing and destroyed aircraft....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still an asset... I guess someone thinks even the broken fuselage of a $65M aircraft is worth guarding until they either recover it or destroy it and gather the parts.

That, or they don't want the Chinese getting ahold of our microwave oven and reverse-engineering it.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is the point of a fast team guarding the plane if it is completely useless and inside the fence line. I'm assuming all the secret stuff has been pulled.

They are guarding it to keep looters and Army soveneir hunters away.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...